top of page

Fact-Checking State Representative Peri Pourier Weston's False Allegations

Writer: Anthony Kathol
Anthony Kathol
6d
8 min read

Today, I am bringing my campaign to a close. Over the past few days, I have had an opportunity to catch up on things around the house, read the news, and see what’s been happening on social media.


I couldn't help but notice what one of my opponents had been saying about me on social media. I had originally planned not to respond, but I believe it is important to correct the record regarding Representative Peri Pourier Weston's November 5, 2026, Facebook post titled "What Actually Happened," published at 9:40 AM.


In her post, Pourier Weston falsely accuses me and my campaign of challenging both her Republican nominating petition and her Independent nominating petition. She further writes that she "had to obtain legal representation to defend my place in this race."



Here are the facts:


Pourier Weston’s Republican Primary Petition


Neither I nor my campaign challenged Pourier Weston's Republican nominating petition.


An individual whom Pourier Weston knows very well brought the issue of an untimely petition filing to my attention. The individual was generous enough to personally purchase the postage to send Pourier Weston's Republican nominating petition by registered mail and witnessed the transaction at the post office.


On March 31, 2026, at 5:44 PM, this individual sent me the following text message reporting the time of the transaction. The message stated:


"Check time on Peri Pourier's petitions. Today at 5:08 pm MST/6:08 CST."

To protect this individual's privacy, I have redacted their identifying information from the screenshot below.



I also have a copy of the registered mail receipt showing the date the postage was purchased and the petition was mailed. Although the receipt does not contain a timestamp, the individual who made the purchase personally witnessed the transaction and subsequently provided me with the specific time in the text message above. I have no reason to doubt the accuracy of the information provided to me by this individual.



One could reasonably expect a four-term State Representative to know when nominating petitions are due and the requirements for submitting them. Under SDCL 12-6-4 and SDCL 12-7-1, nominating petitions must be submitted by registered mail before 5:00 PM local time on the filing deadline. Based on the information provided to me by the individual who personally completed the transaction, Pourier Weston's petition was mailed after the applicable 5:00 PM deadline.


Pourier Weston knew this was an issue, yet she risked her ability to secure ballot access in the 2026 Republican Primary for District 27 State Senate.


On behalf of my campaign, I sent an email to the Office of the Secretary of State inquiring whether a candidate could appear on the ballot if the candidate's nominating petition was submitted after the filing deadline.


Below are copies of my April 1, 2026, email and the response I received from the Secretary of State's office on April 2, 2026.




Based on the Secretary of State's response, I had no further reason to pursue a challenge to Pourier Weston's Republican nominating petition because her submission was already untimely. Contrary to her allegations, I did not file a formal request to have her petition drawn down.


On April 8, 2026, I followed up with the Secretary of State's office because I had not seen Pourier Weston's name listed on the Secretary of State's website as a Republican Primary challenger. I wanted to confirm whether she had been certified as a Republican candidate for the Senate race.



The Secretary of State's office responded by asking which Senate petition I was referring to. I provided a reply but received no further correspondence regarding Pourier Weston's Republican nominating petition.



Since Pourier Weston's name did not appear on the Secretary of State's website, I assumed she had either been denied ballot access or decided not to pursue the District 27 Senate seat. I had also heard that she was seeking the Republican nomination for the Public Utilities Commission (PUC).


Consequently, following the June 2, 2026, Republican Primary, I was declared the Republican nominee for South Dakota State Senate on June 17, 2026.


However, I later learned through a public records request (PUBRECREQ0006490), which I submitted on July 28, 2026, through the South Dakota Citizen's Portal at www.sd.gov, that Pourier Weston indeed had been denied ballot access because her Republican petition was filed late.


Official Letter from the South Dakota Office of the Secretary of State denying Representative Peri Pourier Weston ballot access to run as a Republican candidate for District 27 State Senate in the Republican Primary scheduled for June 2, 2026. (NOTE: Date of letter is April 9, 2026 - one day after I submitted my email requesting confirmation whether State Representative Pourier Weston had been certified as a Republican candidate for the State Senate race.)
Official Letter from the South Dakota Office of the Secretary of State denying Representative Peri Pourier Weston ballot access to run as a Republican candidate for District 27 State Senate in the Republican Primary scheduled for June 2, 2026. (NOTE: Date of letter is April 9, 2026 - one day after I submitted my email requesting confirmation whether State Representative Pourier Weston had been certified as a Republican candidate for the State Senate race.)

Pourier Weston’s Independent Petition and the Court Case


Meanwhile, I was pursuing my legal challenge to Celestine Stadnick's Democratic nominating petition. After my campaign challenged Stadnick's petition before the Secretary of State, the matter moved through the Sixth Circuit Court and ultimately to the South Dakota Supreme Court. While I focused on those legal proceedings, Pourier Weston was busy seeking support from Republican Party convention delegates to secure the PUC nomination.


On Saturday, June 27, 2026. Pourier Weston attended the South Dakota Republican Party Convention in Rapid City, where the election of constitutional officers took place. Our own Secretary of State, Monae Johnson, was sitting in the audience as Pourier Weston delivered a speech explaining why she should be the Republican nominee for PUC.


District 27 State Representative Peri Pourier Weston addresses delegates at the South Dakota Republican Party Convention in Rapid City, explaining why she should be the party's nominee for the Public Utilities Commission. (June 27, 2026)
District 27 State Representative Peri Pourier Weston addresses delegates at the South Dakota Republican Party Convention in Rapid City, explaining why she should be the party's nominee for the Public Utilities Commission. (June 27, 2026)

What I did not know at the time was that the Secretary of State had been ordered by Sixth Circuit Court Judge Margo Northrup to certify Pourier Weston's nominating petition for the 2026 General Election ballot as a District 27 State Senate candidate as an Independent.


The court hearing on Pourier Weston's petition took place on June 5, 2026. Judge Northrup subsequently issued a Peremptory Writ of Mandamus on June 15, 2026, directing the Secretary of State to certify Pourier Weston's Independent petition, with certification effective May 8, 2026.


Just 22 days after appearing in court to secure a place on the District 27 State Senate ballot as an Independent candidate, Pourier Weston was addressing Republican Party convention delegates and seeking their support for the Republican nomination for PUC.


The sequence of events raises a reasonable question about her political priorities: within the span of three weeks, she was pursuing a seat in the State Senate as an Independent candidate through the courts and then seeking a Republican Party nomination for a statewide office.


Interestingly, I had checked the Secretary of State's website numerous times following the April 28, 2026, filing deadline for Independent candidates. I continued checking for nearly two weeks, but I did not see any candidates listed for the District 27 State Senate race on the General Election ballot.



Based on the information available to me at the time, I believed the open Senate seat would be contested only by my Democratic opponent, Celestine Stadnick.


Then, on Tuesday, June 30, 2026, just three days after the South Dakota Republican Party Convention, I came across a Facebook post by Pourier Weston announcing that she had won a court case in Hughes County upholding her petition for District 27 State Senate. See screenshot below:



Based on her Facebook post, I immediately went to the Secretary of State's website, and I noticed that I would be facing not only Stadnick but also Pourier Weston in the race for the open District 27 State Senate seat.



This was a surprise for me. I had been laser-focused on the legal challenge involving my Democratic opponent's petition. Meanwhile, Pourier Weston had successfully pursued her own legal action to secure a place on the General Election ballot as an Independent candidate, something I had not been aware of or anticipated.


Apparently, the Secretary of State had initially decertified Pourier Weston's Independent petition because of a filing-time dispute. However, this time, Pourier Weston prevailed in court because she had submitted her petition by registered mail at 4:26 PM Mountain Time from the Rapid City Post Office. The applicable local time was Mountain Time, where the petition was submitted.


For reference, this matter was heard in Sixth Circuit Court Case 32CIV26-000171, Peri Pourier v. Monae Johnson, Secretary of State.



Because Pourier Weston's Independent petition had initially been decertified, it was not publicly listed on the Secretary of State's website while its certification was being disputed. Consequently, my campaign and other members of the public had no practical opportunity to review and challenge the petition during the applicable statutory challenge period.


Under SDCL 12-1-13, an interested person who has researched a nominating petition may submit an affidavit identifying deficiencies within five business days after the petition is validated and filed with the person in charge of the election.


In Pourier Weston's case, however, her Independent petition was initially decertified, and its certification was subsequently addressed through court proceedings with a hearing scheduled on June 5, 2026. By the time I became aware that the Secretary of State had certified her petition on June 30, 2026, the statutory five-business-day challenge period had already passed. Consequently, I had no opportunity to challenge her petition within the timeframe established by state law.


In other words, the circumstances surrounding her Independent petition were entirely different from those surrounding her Republican Primary petition.


Setting the Record Straight


Pourier Weston's allegation that I challenged her Independent petition is also false.


If she genuinely believes that I requested a copy of her Independent petition or initiated a challenge against it, I encourage her to submit a public records request through the South Dakota Citizen's Portal at https://www.sd.gov/. She can request the records identifying who submitted a South Dakota Petition Copy Request Form for her petition.


I am confident that she will not find my name on any request for a copy of her petition.


The documentary record speaks for itself. Her accusation is false, and she should have verified the facts before making such a public allegation.


The voters of District 27 deserve better from their elected representatives. Thankfully, they recognized the importance of following the law and elected a candidate who submitted his nominating petition on January 12, 2026, well in advance of the March 31, 2026, filing deadline.


Confirmation of Receipt of Nominating Petition by Republican Candidate for District 27 State Senate, Anthony Kathol. (January 12, 2026).
Confirmation of Receipt of Nominating Petition by Republican Candidate for District 27 State Senate, Anthony Kathol. (January 12, 2026).

There is an old proverb that says, "The early bird gets the worm." In this specific matter, it certainly pays to be early.


Pourier Weston could have done the same. As a four-term State Representative who has helped make the laws governing our state for eight years, she should have known the basic requirements for filing a nominating petition.

 

Why would voters entrust someone with the responsibility of making laws if that person cannot follow the basic requirements for seeking public office?


I also wonder whether Pourier Weston will follow up on her social media post with an apology, as she did to me at the candidate forum in Kyle on October 22, 2026.


I have presented the facts because facts matter. It is time for Pourier Weston to either support her allegations with evidence or offer a public apology.


Either way, this will be my final public discussion of my campaign. The election is over, and it is time to move forward. I look forward to representing Peri Pourier Weston, along with the rest of the people of District 27, in the South Dakota State Senate.


Thank you to everyone who supported my campaign and placed their trust in me. I look forward to the work ahead. God bless.


Sincerely,


State Senator-Elect Anthony Kathol

District 27


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Let's Connect

Vote for Anthony Kathol on November 3, 2026 (General Election)

Republican Candidate for South Dakota District 27 State Senate

A leader who delivers with passion and proven results.

​Anthony Kathol was a Commissioned Officer of the United States Public Health Service (USPHS).

Use of his rank, job titles, and photographs in uniform does not imply endorsement

by the USPHS or the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

​

​

Paid for by Kathol for District 27 Campaign Committee

©2026 by Anthony Kathol For South Dakota District 27 State Senate. Powered by GoZoek.com

bottom of page